Yesterday afternoon, a parent asked me whether her daughter should apply to the BS/MD programs. Her grades and test score were on the bubble – that 1460 while admirable, might not cut it. The extracurricular activities were what most kids on a med track do, but in my opinion, it fell short for of what top BS/MDs look for. “One of my kids got into Brown PLME two years ago” I sent the parent. The kid’s resume had three years of research at Memorial Sloan Kettering in NY. I felt bad that the parent took that was a sign her kid shouldn’t apply, which was not my intention.
BS/MD programs have the benefits we all know. No applying to medical school, students won’t have to take the MCAT, and their medical school career starts when they’re in college. How could an applicant and the family not apply to those programs? Let me explain why…
Most of the BS/MD applicants that come to me do not have the resume that gives them a great shot at being accepted. My applicant who did research at MSK also had a focus on early detection of diseases and illness. She worked the front desk of a local clinic in her neighborhood for three years, learned how to help patients, increased her foreign language skills by adding Spanish and French. It was not a surprise when she was accepted to Brown PLME and Penn State Jefferson. Lots of parents don’t see this. They often say to me, “No harm in trying.” But there is. These programs have multiple essays that can take two weeks to finish. That time would be better spent on 2-3 undergraduate programs where the applicant does have a shot.
Another reason not to apply to BS/MD is what the applicant will give up – a true 4 year college life focused not just on becoming a doctor, but to make friends, build a community, and surround themselves with kids who have other interests. Those 5 years can be a great learning and growing experience. There’s no telling what they will learn that will help them apply to medical school and enter healthcare.
Consider wisely a BD/MD program. And if the candidacy isn’t quite there, do not apply. Go to a good 4 year college. Med schools will still be there when they graduate.


